First of all, I
would like to thanks the amazing author who has finally make me read this book
series, Rick Riordan. These books has been on my ebook reader for almost two
years (except for the 4th and 5th book,) and I didn’t think it’s going to
climbed up my TBR list if it was not for Rick Riordan’s review on Goodreads.
So, for that, thank you so much Uncle Rick.
Now, unlike my
other review, this won’t be a one book review, this will be a book series
review and suggestion. I was originally planned to write a one book review for
each books in this series, but then again adulthood sucks and I got no time to
really do it. I REALLY REALLY wanted
to though, because this series is THAT
good and the story is getting more complex in each books. But, I will write a one
book review for the latest book in this series, which is Empire of Storms (hopefully will be up next week.) And it will be
at least two posts review and discussion (and a long one, because there are so
much things to talk about!)
I started
reading Throne of Glass series in
order to crossed off one category from Pop Sugar Reading Challenge this year,
‘A book and its prequel.’ I have so many books in mind before I decided to read
Throne of Glass, but as usual, when
I’m in doubt, I rely on Rick Riordan’s review. And boy, it did not disappointed
me. So far there are 6 books that have been published in this series, one prequel (novella anthology), and book one through five. The last book in this series will come out next year, also one novella and one compendium. So you still have a lot of time to catch up with this series.
Throne of Glass series tells a story about a
skilled young former assassin in Erilea named Celaena Sardothien. After she got
caught by Adarlan’s royal army and spent a year in the salt mines of Endovier, the
Crown Prince of Adarlan offered her a chance to regains her freedom. After she
made a deal with the crown prince, she now has to defeat dozens of other contenders
and become the King’s Champion for four years. Trading her shackles to another,
Celaena begin her quest to once again reclaim her freedom. As we follow
Celaena’s journey we will see mysteries about Erilea and Celaena’s past
unfolded, and what she really destined for, and how she will take control over
her life again.
I read all these
books in the first week of June (except for the 5th book that just came out on
Sept 6th). Actually, no, I need to correct myself, I read all of Sarah J. Maas’
books in the first week of June (including two other books from her other
series). Yes, for the first time in my life I read 7 books in total in the span
of one week, from June 1st to June 7th. In 7 days I sleep like 2 hours a day,
and I just keep on reading, it was crazy.
Now, if you think
that I was in a reading frenzy because I was so in love with the first book in
this series, you’re wrong. If I have to be honest, the first book, Throne of Glass, is my least favorite
one. Don’t get me wrong, I didn’t say that it’s not a good book, it is. It's just in this series, Maas writing keeps getting better and better. Also,
the thing with the first book is, I still found two tropes from YA novels that I
just can’t take anymore, the love triangle and the insta-love. It's overly
used and it gets boring. Though by the end of it I tipped my hat to Mass for
ending the love triangle herself. She also made her character move on in one of the realest way in fantasy book, so kudos to Maas for that.
What send me off
in a reading frenzy is the prequel book, The
Assassin’s Blade. The Assassin’s
Blade actually came out after the second book of Throne of Glass series, which is Crown of Midnight, but I read this one first after Throne of Glass because of the Pop Sugar
Challenge. This book contains five novellas about Celaena Sardothien’s life as
Adarlan’s Assassin and all the events that will lead to Throne of Glass. In this book we will see 16 years old Celaena
working as The
Assassin King’s elite protégé.
Even though I do
love Celaena’s character in the first book, there’s something about her that
really annoyed me. Celaena is a pretty annoying main character, and I said it with all my
love for her. She’s a strong female character who is also an annoying brat. I
admired her as much as I’m annoyed by her. But, The Assassin’s Blade
does her character justice. This book makes her less annoying to me, it made me
understand her action and way of thinking, and really showed me what a wonderful
writer Sarah J. Maas is. Maas added more layer to Celaena’s character, and
made me fall in love with her even more.
That rarely happen, most of the
time a prequel fails to make readers accepting the flaw of the characters and
understand them better, because it somehow feels forced. But the way Maas wrote this book, and elaborate every events and characters to mold Celaena’s
personality is perfect. Thanks to that, this book has pushed me into reading
the next book in this series hence the reading frenzy afterward. So really,
stick with this book series, the first book might be kind of boring but the
rest of it is SO GOOD.
The one thing which really stands
out for me is the characters development. I have to admit one thing that makes
me stand by Sarah J. Maas books is because she wrote character personality and
relationship growth in a such realistic way. Maas never intended for her characters
to be perfect, they’re flawed in so many ways. But, those flaws are what make
her characters real for me. With the way Maas written her characters and how
the plot going on, Throne of Glass become that kind of YA books
which leaning more to the adult sides. In fact, I can said without any
hesitation that the 5th book, Empire of Storms is no longer a YA book, it has
turned into a New Adult book.
The other things that I like
about Throne of Glass is the world building. As the series goes on, the world
is also expanded beautifully. It reminds me so much of the kind of feeling when
I saw the world in George R. R. Martin’s A Song
of Ice and Fire expanded.
In a way, since I read 3rd book in this series, which is Heir of Fire, I feel
like Throne of Glass is like a tamer, less-brutal, easier-to-grasp,
little cousin of ASoIAF.
Though Maas presented
a love triangle and insta-love at some point in this series, she managed to
tackle other boring tropes in the YA series that sickens me. Those tropes
including girls fighting other girls over boys, plain main character who didn’t
realized how attractive they are before their love interest come into their
life, damsel in distress, tomboy characters who hate dresses, male characters
feel like they need to protect female characters because they assumed that they
are stronger than female characters, and so on. Instead, Maas created a series with
tropes that I LOVE to see more in other YA or coming of age books. For example:
• Strong and bad
ass female characters who can also be feminine.
• Female characters
looking out for each other (and they even tag-teaming to sassed out ridiculous
male characters opinion of them.)
• Male characters
cherished their friendship with other male characters.
• Realistic portrayal
of anxiety, depression, PTSD, and more importantly, a story of mental healing.
• Equal treatment
between male and female characters when it comes to fighting and training. Male
characters didn’t look down or underestimate female characters, and female characters
didn’t ask for special treatment. (YASS!)
• Female
characters who are so independent that they can handle problem without any help from male characters.
• Both male and
female characters, no matter how strong they are, still can be victims of
sexual abuse and abusive relationships.
• Female characters
have sexual active lives and are not shamed for it.
• Male characters
that are not warrior-type and are not ashamed by it.
• Males and
Females characters being friends without romantic or sexual attraction for each
other.
And so on.
Honestly though, if I spill more than this I will spoiled the whole plot for you and
ruin your experience with this book.
Now, I have
revealed almost all the good side of this series, but no book series are
without flaws. I honestly don’t mind this one, but one thing that is kind
of problematic is the representation for queer people. But this is something
that you can’t forced. Also, if you’re not a queer person yourself, you have to
be really careful when you write a queer characters. I have seen some other books
where the author write their queer characters as something that is so
stereotypically wrong. And as person with a lot of queer friends, that sickens
me. It feels like they have no respect to queer people whatsoever and just put
them there to ‘spice things up’. So, if Maas didn’t write queer people for that
reason, I can understand that. And it’s not like there is no queer characters in this
series. There are two canonically gay couples that are married and some sort of ‘soulmates’,
one of the main characters are canonically bisexual. Not to mention, some demisexual people
has said that they see one of the pov character in the 5th book as a person
with demisexuality. I can’t say so myself, because I can’t relate to that
myself, and I don't know if Maas intended to do so, but I’m happy that they feel like they have a character that represent them. Also, I honestly like the way Maas write her characters reaction to queer people. They react as if it's something that is so common and not something to be frowned upon. And that's how exactly it should be.
What I personally
feel lacking in this book series is diversity and representation of People of
Color. 80% of Maas main characters are clearly described as white people, some
are racially ambiguous but often saw as white people too. Now, this is actually a tricky
subject, because even though I want Maas to write more POC as her main characters,
this is her story. And I honestly think that this is something that you can’t
forced. That being said, as a girl with brown skin, It would be nice to see Maas highlighted more personal story of her POC characters in the next books.
In conclusion,
even with all its flaws Throne of Glass
is one great book series, and I highly recommend it to you. This series has
earned a special place in my heart alongside Harry Potter series and Percy Jackson
series.
No comments:
Post a Comment